Trust in government and health care reform

Public support for the Affordable Care Act (“ObamaCare”) is at an all time low, even as federal and state officials scramble to prepare the law’s new health insurance exchanges to enroll millions of new consumers this fall. The Kaiser Family Foundation’s April 2013 Health Tracking Poll revealed that only 35% of Americans hold “favorable” views of the ACA, compared to 42% who continue to oppose the law.

The ACA has a growing PR problem. Most Americans neither like nor understand the law’s goals or requirements. The Obama administration continues to pitch the benefits of the ACA in public events around the nation, but Americans aren’t buying the notion. Indeed, support for the ACA has steadily eroded since November 2012 (43% favorable) to 35% today. Supporters of the law hold Republicans responsible for its continued unpopularity, but there’s more here than meets the eye.

Officials are now preoccupied with the nitty gritty details of policy implementation – signing up insurers, designing web sites, and educating the public about the new coverage requirements, penalties, and options for purchasing subsidized insurance. This is a major undertaking, but the Obama administration and supporters of the ACA face a much larger challenge than simply ensuring that the exchanges work as intended. The future of the ACA, and of efforts to expand health insurance coverage to millions of uninsured Americans, ultimately rests on the ability of the president to restore faith in public authority. Recent scandals with the IRS and NSA monitoring of phone calls and emails did little to help matters on this front, but the issue is not new. The most recent Wall Street Journal/NBC News poll in early June found that Americans were evenly divided (48% yes, 48% no) on the question of whether “Government is doing too many things better left to businesses and individuals.”  Seen in this context, weakening public support for the ACA is a symptom of declining trust in government and diminished confidence that government should take on new or expanded roles in the economy. Since less than a third of the public was “generally optimistic” about “our system of government and how well it works” in the most recent NBC News/WSJ poll, the burden of proof rests with the Obama administration to make the case to the public that health care reform is not only in the public’s interest, but that government – not the private sector – is best suited to handle the task. As I argued in the conclusion to Cries of Crisis, “the success of health care reform depends upon the ability of policy makers to convince a skeptical public that progress is not only possible, but also consistent with American ideals. Reformers must persuade Americans to suspend their doubts, if not outright hostility, towards government.” Until then, the future of the ACA rests on shaky ground.


Share your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s